What the Market Is Really Telling You
If you own a rental property in Edmonton and it’s been sitting vacant for weeks or even months, you’re probably asking yourself a simple question: Why isn’t my property renting? Every month that passes means another mortgage payment, property tax bill, insurance payment and potentially condo fees or utilities without rental income coming in. It’s frustrating, especially when you believe your property is worth a certain amount and the market doesn’t seem to agree.
Unfortunately, many landlords aren’t getting the information they need to understand what’s happening. They might hear that the rental market is slow, that their property is being advertised or that their management company is waiting for the right tenant. While those explanations may be true, they don’t necessarily help the owner understand the problem or what needs to change. In my opinion, a property manager’s responsibility goes well beyond placing an advertisement and waiting for someone to apply. They should be studying the market, tracking activity, identifying problems and communicating recommendations to the property owner.
I’ve been investing in real estate since 2003. Like many investors, I started out not knowing nearly as much as I thought I did. I hired property management companies to look after my investments and eventually went through three different companies before deciding to manage my properties myself. Over time, I developed systems that worked, learned from mistakes and eventually established my own property management business in 2010, which we rebranded as TILT Property Group in 2017. Today, TILT manages approximately 860 rental properties in the Edmonton area, and I personally own approximately 120 rental properties.
Over more than two decades of investing, I’ve experienced strong rental markets, slow rental markets, difficult tenants, extended vacancies and just about every challenge that comes with owning rental property. One of the most important lessons I’ve learned is that the rental market will usually tell you why your property isn’t renting. You just need to know how to interpret the information.
No Calls and No Showings? Your Asking Rent Is Probably Too High.
One of the simplest principles we follow at TILT is that when a rental property is being properly advertised but isn’t generating calls or showings, the asking rent is usually too high. Owners sometimes have a specific rental amount in mind based on what the previous tenant paid, what their mortgage costs or what another property rented for several months ago. Unfortunately, none of those things necessarily reflect today’s rental market. Prospective tenants are comparing your property against everything else available, and if they can find better value elsewhere, that’s where they’ll go.
Imagine two similar rental properties advertised in the same Edmonton neighbourhood. One is listed for $1,900 per month and the other for $2,200. If the size, condition, location and amenities are comparable, which one do you think prospective tenants will investigate first? Most will naturally gravitate toward the property offering better value. That’s why we track competing rental listings and monitor how prospective tenants respond to the properties we’re advertising. We need to understand what tenants are seeing and how our listings compare.
This is sometimes a difficult conversation to have with property owners because nobody wants to hear that their investment may generate less rental income than expected. I understand that completely because I’m a landlord myself. But there’s an important difference between what an owner wants to receive and what the market is prepared to pay. We can advertise a property at almost any price the owner chooses, but we can’t force prospective tenants to pay more than they believe the property is worth.
The financial consequences of holding out for a higher rent can also be significant. Suppose a property is advertised at $2,200 per month, but comparable properties suggest that $2,000 is more realistic. The owner might resist reducing the asking rent because they don’t want to lose $200 per month, or $2,400 over a full year. However, if the property sits vacant for an additional two months while waiting for the higher rent, that’s $4,000 in potential rental income at the lower rate that hasn’t been collected. In that situation, the owner could lose more money waiting for the higher rent than they would have by accepting the lower rent for an entire year.
Reducing the asking rent doesn’t guarantee a qualified tenant will apply, but it illustrates why vacancy costs need to be part of the conversation. Sometimes the most expensive decision a landlord makes is refusing to adjust the rent when the market is clearly telling them it’s too high.
Lots of Calls and Showings but No Applications? Look at the Property.
The second major principle we follow is equally straightforward. If a rental property is generating plenty of calls and showings but very few applications, there’s a good chance the property’s condition, layout or features don’t justify the asking rent. Prospective tenants are interested enough in the advertisement to book a showing, but something changes when they see the property in person. That difference between initial interest and actual applications is valuable information, and it’s something a good property manager should be paying attention to.
Sometimes the problem is obvious. The flooring may be damaged, the walls may need painting, the kitchen may be outdated or the property may not be as clean as prospective tenants expect. Other times, the issue is less straightforward. The layout might be unusual, the bedrooms might be smaller than expected or the property might have features that appeal to a limited group of tenants. None of these things necessarily make it a bad property, but they can affect what someone is willing to pay to live there.
We recently managed an Edmonton rental property that illustrates this situation. The property was somewhat unusual, with features that wouldn’t necessarily appeal to everyone. It also had flooring that needed attention and some interior features that weren’t particularly attractive to prospective tenants. Our team conducted numerous showings, but the property wasn’t generating the applications we needed. Based on the response and the condition of the property, I believed the asking rent was several hundred dollars higher than the market would likely support.
The important thing to understand is that the advertising was working well enough to generate interest. Prospective tenants were booking appointments and viewing the property, but they weren’t choosing to rent it. That’s a very different problem from a property that isn’t generating any inquiries at all. In this situation, the solution may involve improving the property’s condition, reducing the asking rent or a combination of both.
A property manager can’t force prospective tenants to like a property or agree with its price. What we can do is collect information, explain what we’re seeing and recommend changes. Ultimately, the owner decides whether to act on those recommendations, but at least they’re making that decision with an understanding of what the market is telling us.
The Goal Isn’t Dozens of Showings. It’s a Few Good Applications.
Some property owners believe that a successful rental listing should generate dozens of inquiries and showings. I don’t necessarily agree. At TILT, our goal isn’t to show a property to as many people as possible. Our goal is to attract suitable prospective tenants, generate a manageable number of showings and receive applications from people who meet our screening requirements. Ideally, we’d like to see a few showings and a couple of good applications. That generally tells us the property’s price, condition and presentation are reasonably aligned with what prospective tenants are looking for.
Of course, rental activity varies depending on the neighbourhood, property type, time of year and overall market conditions. But the principle remains the same. We’re not measuring success simply by how many people walk through the door. We’re measuring whether the property is attracting suitable applicants at a rental rate the market will support.
This brings me to something I believe is even more important than finding someone willing to rent a property: finding someone who should actually be approved to live there.
Finding a Tenant Isn’t Always Difficult. Finding the Right Tenant Is.
One of the biggest mistakes landlords can make is becoming so frustrated with a vacancy that they lower their tenant-screening standards just to get someone into the property. I understand the temptation. Every vacant month costs money, and eventually owners want the problem solved. But placing the wrong tenant can turn a relatively manageable vacancy into a much larger financial problem involving unpaid rent, property damage, legal expenses and additional months without rental income.
At TILT, we approach tenant screening with three fundamental questions. First, is this someone who is likely to take reasonable care of the property? Second, can they afford the rent and demonstrate an ability to pay reliably? Third, if the tenant defaults on their obligations, is there a realistic legal and financial avenue to recover what is owed? That final question is something I believe many landlords overlook. Obtaining a legal judgment and actually collecting the money are two very different things, and landlords need to understand that risk.
Our screening process involves multiple stages, including reviewing applications, communicating with prospective tenants, checking relevant financial information and references, and having our management team review the application before presenting a recommendation to the owner. We assess applicants using lawful, relevant criteria and comply with applicable tenancy, privacy and human-rights requirements. No screening process can guarantee that a tenant will never default or cause damage, but thorough screening can help reduce avoidable risks.
Another important difference at TILT is that the property owner has final approval of the tenant. We don’t believe a management company should have complete control over who gets to live in someone else’s investment. Our responsibility is to complete the screening, explain our findings and make a recommendation. The owner then makes the final decision based on that information.
This is particularly important in slower rental markets. Just because fewer people are applying doesn’t mean we should automatically lower our standards. A vacant property is expensive, but a poorly selected tenant can be considerably more expensive.
A Slow Rental Market Exposes Weak Property Management.
I’ve watched Edmonton’s rental market change many times since I started investing in 2003. When the market is strong, property management can look relatively easy. You advertise a property, receive inquiries, arrange showings and secure a tenant. Owners are happy because their properties are producing income, and there isn’t much reason for them to question the management company.
But when the market slows, things change. Properties can take longer to rent, competing listings become more important and prospective tenants have more choices. Owners become increasingly concerned about vacancy costs and want to know what’s happening. That’s when the quality of a property management company’s systems, communication and decision-making becomes much more visible.
A property manager who simply places an advertisement and waits for the phone to ring may struggle in those conditions. The job requires more than advertising. It requires understanding what the market is doing, monitoring activity, recognizing when something isn’t working and recommending adjustments. It also requires being willing to have difficult conversations with owners when the evidence suggests their expectations aren’t realistic.
One of the most common frustrations I hear from property owners is that they don’t know what’s happening with their rental property. Their unit has been vacant for weeks or months, but they don’t know how many inquiries it’s received, how many showings have taken place or what prospective tenants are saying. Sometimes they don’t even know whether their asking rent is competitive. In my opinion, that’s unacceptable. An owner should never have to continually chase their property manager just to find out what’s happening with their investment.
Communication Is One of the Most Important Parts of Property Management.
At TILT, we provide owners with leasing updates every two weeks while their properties are being marketed. These updates include information about inquiries, calls, showings, competing rental properties and relevant feedback from prospective tenants. When the information suggests a change is needed, we recommend a rent adjustment, property improvement or another appropriate step. The purpose isn’t simply to send an email saying we’re still working on the property. The purpose is to give the owner meaningful information they can use to make decisions.
For example, if a property has received almost no inquiries over the previous two weeks, we need to examine the asking rent and how the property compares with competing listings. If we’ve conducted numerous showings without receiving applications, we need to investigate whether the property’s condition or features justify the price. If we’re receiving applications but the applicants aren’t meeting our screening requirements, that’s another situation we need to explain. Each of these scenarios tells us something different and may require a different response.
Communication becomes even more important when the news isn’t particularly good. Nobody enjoys telling an owner that their property needs repairs or that their asking rent is too high. But avoiding those conversations doesn’t help anyone. I believe owners deserve honest information, even when it isn’t what they want to hear. They can then decide whether to follow the recommendation, make a different adjustment or continue advertising at the existing price.
The owner always retains control of those decisions. However, that also means understanding the consequences of choosing not to act. If the market is consistently telling us a property is overpriced and the owner chooses to maintain the asking rent, the vacancy may continue. We will keep doing the work, but we can’t promise a result that the market isn’t supporting.
The Highest Asking Rent Doesn’t Always Produce the Best Return.
As a property investor, I look at rental properties from a financial perspective. It’s easy to become focused on achieving the highest possible monthly rent, but that number alone doesn’t determine whether a property is performing well. Vacancy, maintenance, tenant quality and operating expenses all affect the investment’s overall return.
Consider two similar properties. Property A is advertised at $2,200 per month but sits vacant for three months before renting for the remaining nine months of the year. Its gross rental income for that year is $19,800. Property B is advertised at $2,000 per month and remains rented for the entire twelve months, generating $24,000 in gross rental income. Despite having a lower monthly rent, Property B produces $4,200 more income over the year.
These are simplified examples, and real investment performance also depends on expenses, tenant turnover, maintenance and other factors. But they illustrate why I encourage owners to look beyond the advertised rental rate. An additional $100 or $200 per month isn’t necessarily worth pursuing if doing so results in a significantly longer vacancy.
I also believe this is where experience matters. A good property manager should understand the financial impact of vacancy and help owners evaluate their options. That doesn’t mean automatically recommending the lowest rent. It means using current market information to find a reasonable balance between rental income, vacancy risk and attracting a qualified tenant.
How Do You Know Whether Your Property Manager Is Doing a Good Job?
If your Edmonton rental property has been vacant for an extended period, I encourage you to ask your management company some straightforward questions. How many inquiries has the property received? How many showings have been completed? What feedback are prospective tenants providing? What comparable properties are currently available in the neighbourhood? How does your asking rent compare with those listings, and what adjustments does your manager recommend?
You should also ask how often you’ll receive updates and who is responsible for communicating with you. If you’re dealing with one individual, what happens when that person is away, leaves the company or becomes overwhelmed? Is there a team available to help, or does everything depend on one person? These are important considerations because communication problems often become more noticeable when a property is difficult to rent.
Perhaps the most important question is whether your property manager is providing recommendations or simply reporting that the property remains vacant. There is a significant difference between saying, “We haven’t received any applications,” and explaining that the property has generated ten showings without applications, comparable rentals are priced several hundred dollars lower, and prospective tenants have raised concerns about the flooring. The second explanation gives the owner something useful to work with.
I don’t believe an extended vacancy automatically means a management company is doing a poor job. Even a very good property manager cannot control market demand or guarantee that a qualified tenant will apply. But an owner should be able to see that the company is actively working on the property, understands the market and is communicating what needs to happen next.
Should You Change Property Management Companies if Your Property Isn’t Renting?
Not necessarily. I own rental properties myself, and I know how frustrating extended vacancies can be. But I also understand that changing management companies doesn’t automatically change the rental market. If a property is overpriced or needs improvements, those issues don’t disappear simply because another company takes over.
Before deciding to switch, I’d look at whether the existing management company is doing the work. Are they advertising effectively, responding to inquiries, conducting showings, tracking market activity, screening applicants properly and providing regular recommendations? If they’re doing those things consistently, the issue may be the property’s asking rent, condition or current market demand rather than the management company itself.
On the other hand, if you’re receiving little communication, no meaningful market information and no recommendations about what should change, I believe you have a legitimate reason to question the service you’re receiving. Property management isn’t simply about collecting rent when everything is going well. It’s about managing the property professionally when things become more challenging.
Changing management companies won’t change the rental market, but changing to a company with stronger systems, better communication and a more proactive approach can make a significant difference in your experience as a property owner.
What We Promise Property Owners at TILT.
I don’t promise that we’ll rent every property within 30 days, achieve the highest rental rate in Edmonton or find a tenant who will never cause problems. Nobody can responsibly guarantee those outcomes. What I do promise is that our team will work hard, communicate consistently, conduct thorough tenant screening and provide honest recommendations based on what the market is telling us.
I started this business because I experienced firsthand the frustrations of dealing with property management companies as an investor. Poor tenant placement, uncontrolled spending and poor communication were problems I encountered myself. Those experiences shaped how TILT operates today. We believe owners should approve the tenants moving into their properties, receive their rental payments directly and maintain control over major spending decisions. Our job is to handle the day-to-day work while keeping owners informed and in control.
We also understand that every property is different. Some properties are easy to rent, while others require more time, adjustments or improvements. Our responsibility is to recognize those differences, communicate honestly and work with owners to make informed decisions. Sometimes that means recommending something the owner doesn’t particularly want to hear, but I’d rather have an honest conversation than make a promise I can’t deliver.
Final Thoughts: Let the Rental Market Tell You What Needs to Change.
If your Edmonton rental property isn’t renting, the first step isn’t necessarily changing management companies or dramatically reducing the asking rent. The first step is understanding what’s actually happening. Look at the inquiries, showings, applications, competing listings and feedback from prospective tenants. That information will usually point you toward the problem and help determine what adjustments make sense.
If there’s no interest, examine the asking rent and advertising. If there are plenty of showings but no applications, examine the property’s condition and how it compares with the competition. If applications are coming in but nobody meets appropriate screening standards, continue evaluating the market without sacrificing tenant quality. Throughout the process, your property manager should be communicating regularly and making recommendations supported by the information available.
After more than 20 years of investing in real estate, I firmly believe that good property management isn’t about telling owners what they want to hear. It’s about doing the work, understanding the market, protecting the investment and communicating honestly. That’s the philosophy we’ve built TILT around, and it’s what I expect from our team every day.
We can’t control the rental market, but we can make sure our owners understand what it’s telling us.
If your rental property has been sitting vacant and you’re frustrated by poor communication or a lack of meaningful recommendations, we’d be happy to explain how TILT approaches property management.
We believe property owners deserve regular updates, thorough tenant screening, informed recommendations and control over the important decisions affecting their investments.
TILT Property Group — Edmonton Property Management
Your Property. Your Money. Your Decisions.
Let’s Talk About Your Property.







