7 Things Every Landlord Should Expect
Edmonton Property Management Insights with Jared Hope
By Jared Hope
Real Estate Investor Since 2003 | Owner, TILT Property Group
Hiring a property management company should make owning rental property easier. You’re paying someone to handle tenant concerns, coordinate maintenance, manage vacancies and look after the day-to-day responsibilities that come with being a landlord. Ideally, that allows you to enjoy the benefits of owning an investment property without having to personally deal with every problem that arises.
But how do you know whether your property management company is actually doing a good job?
It’s a question I believe more landlords should be asking. Many owners judge their property manager almost entirely by whether the rent arrives each month. If the property is occupied and the tenant isn’t complaining, everything must be going well. Unfortunately, that’s not always the case. Poor tenant screening, unnecessary maintenance expenses, inadequate documentation and weak communication can go unnoticed for months or even years, particularly when the rental market is strong.
I’ve been investing in real estate since 2003. When I started, I knew very little about property management and assumed hiring a professional company would be the easiest way to protect my investments. Over time, I went through three different management companies and became frustrated with many of the same problems I still hear landlords complain about today. Eventually, I began managing my own properties, developed systems based on what I was learning and established my own property management business in 2010.
Today, after more than two decades of investing and managing rental properties, I’ve come to believe that good property management isn’t defined by how smoothly things operate when everything is going well. It’s defined by the systems, communication and decisions that protect an owner’s investment when challenges arise.
Not every property management company needs to operate the same way. Different companies have different structures, fee arrangements and approaches, and what works for one landlord may not work for another. However, there are certain standards I believe every property owner should expect.
Here are seven areas I’d examine when evaluating an Edmonton property management company.
1. Are You Receiving Meaningful Communication?
One of the most common frustrations I hear from rental property owners is poor communication. It’s rarely just about how quickly someone answers an email. The bigger issue is whether the owner understands what’s happening with their investment and whether the manager is providing useful information.
Consider a property that’s been vacant for six weeks. The owner contacts the management company and receives a response saying the property is still being advertised and they’re waiting for applications. Technically, that’s an update, but it doesn’t explain very much. How many people have inquired about the property? How many showings have taken place? What feedback are prospective tenants providing? Are comparable properties renting for less? Without that information, the owner has no way of knowing whether the problem is the asking rent, the property’s condition or simply a slower rental market.
In my opinion, a property manager should be providing meaningful leasing updates at least every couple of weeks while a property is being marketed. Those updates should include inquiries, showings, applications, relevant market comparisons and recommendations when something needs to change. Owners shouldn’t have to continually chase their manager to find out what’s happening.
The same principle applies to maintenance and tenant issues. If a furnace breaks down, a tenant falls behind on rent or an unexpected repair becomes necessary, the owner should receive a clear explanation of the situation, the steps being taken and any decisions that require their involvement. Communication doesn’t always mean delivering good news. Sometimes it means having an uncomfortable conversation about an expense, a tenant problem or a rental price that the market simply isn’t supporting.
I’ve always believed that owners can handle bad news far better than they can handle being left in the dark.
2. How Thoroughly Are Prospective Tenants Being Screened?
Finding someone willing to rent a property is one thing. Finding someone who is likely to pay their rent, look after the property and fulfill their obligations under the lease is something entirely different.
Tenant placement is one of the most important decisions made during the management of a rental property. A good tenant can make ownership relatively straightforward, while a poorly selected tenant can create months of unpaid rent, property damage, legal expenses and considerable frustration. That’s why I believe tenant screening deserves far more attention than simply collecting an application and checking a credit score.
When evaluating a management company, I’d ask exactly what happens between receiving an application and approving a tenant. Are references verified? Is employment or income information reviewed where appropriate? Are inconsistencies investigated? Does more than one person review the application? What happens if an applicant meets some screening requirements but raises concerns in other areas?
There are three fundamental questions I consider important when evaluating prospective tenants. First, is there reasonable evidence that the applicant will take care of the property? Second, can the applicant afford the rent and demonstrate a reliable ability to pay? Third, if the tenant defaults on their financial obligations, are there realistic and lawful options for recovering what is owed? These considerations must always be assessed using consistent, legally permissible criteria and in accordance with applicable tenancy, privacy and human-rights requirements.
That final consideration is often overlooked. Obtaining a legal judgment against someone and actually collecting the money are two very different things. A landlord can spend considerable time and money pursuing unpaid rent, only to discover that recovery is difficult or impossible. Understanding financial risk before approving a tenant is therefore an important part of protecting an investment.
I’d also ask who makes the final decision about tenant approval. Some management companies make that decision independently, while others involve the owner. Neither arrangement should be a surprise after the management agreement is signed. Personally, I’ve always believed that property owners should have the final say over who moves into their investment, provided decisions comply with the law.
No screening process can guarantee a perfect tenant. People lose jobs, relationships change and unexpected circumstances arise. But a thorough, consistent screening process can help reduce avoidable risks.
3. Who Controls Your Rent and Maintenance Spending?
When comparing property management companies, many owners focus on the monthly management fee. That’s understandable, but I believe it’s equally important to understand how the company handles rental income and maintenance expenses.
One of the first questions I’d ask is where the tenant’s rent goes after it’s paid. Does the money go directly to the property owner, or does the management company collect it first, deduct its fees and expenses, and then distribute the remaining balance? Different companies use different payment structures, and owners should understand exactly how their money is handled, when they’ll receive it and what financial reporting is available.
There are legitimate reasons for different payment arrangements, but my personal preference has always been for rental income to go directly to the owner whenever the management structure allows it. I believe this gives owners greater visibility and control over their money. It also makes management fees and maintenance expenses easier to review separately rather than having them automatically deducted before the owner receives the rent.
Maintenance spending raises similar questions. Every rental property requires repairs, and a manager needs enough authority to deal with routine problems efficiently. However, owners should know how much their manager can spend without approval, what happens when a repair exceeds that amount and how emergency expenses are handled.
For example, imagine a tenant reports that a dishwasher isn’t working. The manager arranges a repair, but the technician determines that replacing the appliance would be more economical. Who decides whether to repair or replace it? Does the owner receive a quote? Are alternative options considered? What documentation is provided afterward?
These may seem like small details, but they become important when you own several rental properties and maintenance expenses begin adding up. A few unnecessary replacements or poorly managed repairs can easily outweigh the savings from choosing a company with a slightly lower management fee.
I don’t believe owners should have to approve every minor repair or personally coordinate contractors. That defeats much of the purpose of hiring a property manager. However, they should understand the spending authority they’ve granted and maintain meaningful control over major financial decisions.
4. Is Your Property Manager Actively Managing Vacancies?
A vacant rental property can become expensive very quickly. Mortgage payments, insurance, property taxes, utilities and other expenses continue even when the property isn’t generating income. That’s why I believe vacancy management is one of the clearest ways to evaluate how actively a property manager is working on an owner’s behalf.
Advertising a rental property is only the beginning. The real work involves monitoring the response, understanding competing listings, communicating with prospective tenants and recognizing when the market is telling you something needs to change.
Over the years, I’ve developed two simple principles that help explain many rental vacancies.
The first is that when a property is properly advertised but generates very few inquiries or showings, the asking rent is often too high relative to what else is available. Prospective tenants are comparing properties, and if they can find better value elsewhere, they’ll usually investigate those options first. Of course, advertising quality, seasonality and property type also affect activity, so those factors need to be considered before recommending a price reduction.
The second principle is that when a property generates plenty of showings but very few applications, the problem may be the property’s condition, layout or features relative to the asking rent. People are interested enough to book an appointment, but something about the property isn’t meeting their expectations when they see it in person.
These situations require different responses. A property receiving no inquiries may need a pricing or advertising adjustment. A property receiving numerous showings without applications may need improvements, a price adjustment or a combination of both.
I’ve also learned that holding out for the highest possible rent doesn’t always produce the best financial result. Suppose an owner wants $2,200 per month, but comparable properties suggest $2,000 is more realistic. If the property sits vacant for an additional two months while waiting for the higher rent, that’s $4,000 in potential income at the lower rate that hasn’t been collected. The extra $200 per month would take twenty months to recover that difference, assuming the property eventually rents for the higher amount and all other factors remain equal.
This doesn’t mean a property manager should automatically recommend reducing the rent whenever a property is vacant. It means they should be tracking the market, interpreting the response and providing recommendations supported by actual information.
A good manager can’t guarantee how quickly a property will rent. But they should be able to explain what they’re doing, what results they’re seeing and what they recommend next.
5. Who Is Actually Managing Your Property?
When hiring a property management company, landlords often spend time speaking with a salesperson, company owner or senior manager. That person may be knowledgeable, professional and very responsive. But once the agreement is signed, who actually looks after the property?
This is something I believe owners should investigate more carefully.
Will you have one property manager responsible for everything, or will different team members handle leasing, maintenance, accounting and tenant communication? Is there a central system where information is documented? What happens when your primary contact goes on vacation, becomes overwhelmed or leaves the company?
There’s nothing inherently wrong with having one main contact. In fact, some owners prefer it because they know exactly who to call. The risk arises when one person becomes responsible for everything and there’s no reliable backup system. If that employee leaves, important information about the property, tenants, maintenance history and outstanding issues can be difficult to transfer.
Property management involves a surprising number of moving parts. There are inquiries to answer, showings to coordinate, applications to review, leases to prepare, inspections to complete, maintenance requests to manage, invoices to process and tenant concerns to address. As the number of properties increases, good systems and clearly defined responsibilities become increasingly important.
I’d also ask how many properties the company manages and how many employees support those properties. There’s no perfect number of rental doors per staff member because the answer depends on property types, technology, maintenance arrangements and how responsibilities are divided. However, understanding the company’s staffing structure can give you a better idea of whether it has the resources to provide consistent service.
Ultimately, you’re not just hiring a person. You’re hiring the systems, processes and organization behind that person. Those systems become especially important when something unexpected happens.
6. What Happens When There’s an Emergency?
Property management problems don’t always occur between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. Furnaces stop working during Edmonton winters, water leaks happen on weekends and tenants sometimes experience urgent problems in the middle of the night.
When evaluating a management company, I would ask exactly how after-hours emergencies are handled. Is there a dedicated emergency phone number? Who answers it? Does the company have access to contractors or maintenance personnel who can respond? What happens if an emergency requires immediate spending to prevent additional property damage?
There’s an important distinction between routine maintenance and genuine emergencies. A dripping faucet or a broken cabinet hinge may be inconvenient, but it generally doesn’t require someone to respond at midnight. A major water leak, loss of heat during freezing temperatures or another situation involving immediate safety or property risks is different. A management company should have clear procedures for identifying those situations and responding appropriately.
I’d also want to know how the owner is kept informed. If emergency work is required to protect the property, the manager may need to act before obtaining ordinary spending approval, depending on the circumstances and management agreement. But that doesn’t eliminate the responsibility to document what happened, explain why the work was necessary and provide supporting information afterward.
One suggestion I’ve made to landlords over the years is to evaluate how a company handles communication outside normal business hours before hiring it. That doesn’t mean expecting an employee to answer routine questions late at night. It means understanding whether there is a reliable process for urgent situations and whether tenants and owners know how to access it.
A professional website and friendly sales presentation are important, but they’re not nearly as valuable as knowing someone will respond when your property has a serious problem.
7. Does Your Property Manager Take Accountability When Things Go Wrong?
No property management company is perfect. After more than two decades in real estate, I can tell you that unexpected problems are part of owning rental properties. Tenants make mistakes, contractors make mistakes, employees make mistakes and sometimes circumstances develop in ways nobody could reasonably predict.
What matters is how those situations are handled.
I believe a good management company should be able to explain what happened, what information was available at the time, what decisions were made and what steps are being taken to resolve the issue. If the company made a mistake, it should acknowledge that and work toward an appropriate solution. If the problem arose because of a tenant, contractor or another circumstance outside the company’s control, the owner should still receive a clear explanation supported by the available facts.
Documentation is particularly important. Maintenance records, inspection reports, invoices, photographs and communication histories can all help establish what happened and why certain decisions were made. Without proper records, relatively straightforward disagreements can become much more difficult to resolve.
I also believe accountability needs to be fair. A management company shouldn’t automatically blame an employee or contractor simply because an owner is unhappy with an outcome. Sometimes the team followed the correct procedures and the result was still disappointing. Other times, a genuine mistake occurred and needs to be addressed. The goal should be to establish the facts and deal with the situation responsibly rather than simply telling someone what they want to hear.
When evaluating a management company, ask how complaints are handled, who reviews disputed decisions and what documentation is available when questions arise. A company that is willing to explain its decisions and take responsibility for legitimate mistakes is generally one I’d have more confidence in than one that becomes defensive whenever a problem occurs.
Does a Lower Management Fee Actually Save You Money?
One of the most common questions landlords ask when comparing property management companies is how much they charge. That’s a reasonable question, but I don’t believe it should be the only one.
Consider a property renting for $2,000 per month. A difference of two percentage points in management fees represents $40 per month, or $480 per year, before taxes and any additional charges. That may seem like meaningful savings, but one avoidable month of vacancy, an unnecessary repair or a poorly screened tenant can quickly cost considerably more.
That doesn’t mean an expensive management company is automatically better. I’ve seen enough of this industry to know that higher fees don’t guarantee better service. The important question is what you’re receiving for the money and whether the company is helping protect the overall performance of your investment.
As a landlord, I’d rather pay a reasonable fee to a company I trust than save a small amount each month while constantly worrying about what’s happening with my property. Good communication, thorough screening, responsible maintenance and reliable systems all have value, even when that value doesn’t appear as a separate line on a financial statement.
My advice is to compare management companies based on their overall service, not simply their advertised monthly percentage. Ask questions, understand the agreement and choose the company you believe will look after your investment properly.
Should You Change Property Management Companies?
If you’re unhappy with your current property manager, I wouldn’t automatically recommend switching companies. First, identify exactly what’s causing the frustration. Is the company failing to communicate? Are maintenance expenses higher than expected? Has the property been vacant without meaningful recommendations? Are you concerned about tenant screening or how decisions are being made?
Once you’ve identified the problems, have a conversation with the company’s management team. Explain your concerns and ask what can be done to address them. Sometimes expectations weren’t clearly established at the beginning, or a communication problem can be corrected with better processes.
However, if you’ve raised the same concerns repeatedly and nothing changes, it may be time to explore alternatives. Before making that decision, review your management agreement carefully, including termination provisions, notice periods and any applicable fees. You should also understand how leases, tenant records, deposits, maintenance information and other documents will be transferred if you appoint a new manager.
Changing management companies won’t automatically solve every problem. If your property is overpriced, needs repairs or is located in an area with limited rental demand, those issues will still exist. But working with a company that provides better communication, stronger systems and more proactive recommendations can make a meaningful difference in your experience as an owner.
The decision should ultimately come down to trust. Do you believe your property manager is looking after your investment, giving you accurate information and making decisions with your interests in mind? If the answer is consistently no, it’s reasonable to question whether the relationship is still working.
Final Thoughts: Good Property Management Is About Trust and Accountability.
When I first started investing in real estate in 2003, I assumed hiring a professional property manager would make everything easier. What I eventually learned is that the quality of property management can have a significant impact on both the financial performance of a rental property and the owner’s overall experience.
Over the years, I’ve come to believe that good property management comes down to a few fundamentals: thorough tenant screening, responsible spending, proactive vacancy management, dependable systems, meaningful communication and accountability when something goes wrong.
You shouldn’t expect your property manager to prevent every vacancy, eliminate all maintenance expenses or guarantee that every tenant will fulfill their obligations. Those expectations aren’t realistic. But you should expect the company to work professionally, provide honest information, document important decisions and communicate when your investment needs attention.
I also encourage landlords to remember that property management is a working relationship. Owners and managers won’t always agree, and sometimes a manager needs to recommend something an owner doesn’t want to hear. That’s part of the job. A good relationship allows for those conversations while keeping everyone focused on protecting the investment.
The best property management company isn’t necessarily the cheapest, the biggest or the one making the most promises. It’s the one you trust to look after your property and tell you the truth when something needs to change.
About the Author
Jared Hope has been investing in real estate since 2003. After experiencing challenges with several property management companies, he began managing his own rental investments and established a property management business in 2010. The company was rebranded as TILT Property Group in 2017 and now manages approximately 860 residential rental properties in the Edmonton area.
Through Edmonton Property Management Insights, Jared shares practical lessons from more than two decades of investing, owning and managing rental properties.
TILT Property Group
Your Property. Your Money. Your Decisions.












