Finding a Tenant Is Easy. Finding the Right Tenant Is Hard.

0

The Three Questions Every Landlord Should Ask

Edmonton Property Management Insights with Jared Hope

By Jared Hope
Real Estate Investor Since 2003 | Owner, TILT Property Group

Finding someone who wants to rent your property is usually not the most difficult part of being a landlord. Finding someone who will reliably pay the rent, look after your investment and fulfill their obligations throughout the tenancy is an entirely different challenge.

When a rental property is vacant, there’s pressure to get it rented. Mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance and other expenses continue whether someone is living there or not. Every week without a tenant means another week without rental income, and that can make even experienced landlords anxious to approve an application.

I’ve been investing in real estate since 2003, and one of the most important lessons I’ve learned is that the wrong tenant can cost considerably more than a few additional weeks of vacancy. A tenant who stops paying rent, causes significant damage or refuses to fulfill their obligations can turn what should be a relatively straightforward investment into an expensive and frustrating experience.

When I first started investing, I didn’t fully appreciate how much tenant selection mattered. I hired property management companies, trusted their processes and assumed they were making the right decisions. After going through three different management companies and eventually taking over the management of my own properties, I began developing a much more structured approach.

Today, after more than two decades of owning and managing rental properties, I’ve simplified my tenant screening philosophy down to three fundamental questions.

1. Can the applicant afford the rent and reliably pay it every month?

2. Will the applicant take care of the property?

3. If the applicant fails to meet those obligations, can the landlord successfully pursue a legal claim and realistically collect what is owed?

These three questions guide how we evaluate prospective tenants. Our objective is to be satisfied with all three before recommending approval. If an applicant presents a legitimate financial concern, we may consider a qualified co-signer or guarantor who can provide additional financial protection.

It sounds relatively simple, but answering those questions properly requires more than collecting an application and running a credit check.

Here’s why I believe this approach matters and what Edmonton rental property owners should understand before approving their next tenant.

1. Can the Applicant Afford the Rent and Reliably Pay Every Month?

This is the first question most landlords consider, and for good reason. If someone cannot reasonably afford the rent, the risk of missed payments and financial difficulties increases.

But determining whether someone can afford a property isn’t as simple as looking at their annual salary.

Consider a rental property priced at $2,200 per month. An applicant may have a reasonable income but also carry substantial financial obligations. Another applicant may have a less conventional income arrangement but a strong financial history and sufficient resources to meet their obligations.

The objective should be to understand the applicant’s financial circumstances using relevant, verifiable information rather than relying on assumptions.

A thorough screening process may include reviewing appropriate proof of income, verifying employment or other legitimate income sources, examining credit information with the applicant’s consent and considering relevant financial obligations. Any assessment should be consistent, reasonable and compliant with Alberta’s human-rights and privacy requirements.

I also believe it’s important to look beyond the numbers on an application. If information doesn’t match, documents appear inconsistent or something requires clarification, those questions should be addressed before making a decision.

That doesn’t automatically mean an applicant is unsuitable. There can be perfectly reasonable explanations for differences in documentation or changes in financial circumstances. But the screening process should establish enough reliable information to support an informed decision.

One of the mistakes I see landlords make is focusing too heavily on whether the applicant can afford the first month’s rent and security deposit. Those payments are important, but the real question is whether the tenant can reasonably maintain the payments throughout the tenancy.

A successful rental investment depends on consistent income over time, not simply collecting the first payment.

2. Will the Applicant Take Care of the Property?

The second question is equally important, although it can be more difficult to answer.

As a rental property owner, you’re trusting someone with an asset that may be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. You want reasonable confidence that the tenant will respect the property, report maintenance concerns appropriately and fulfill the responsibilities outlined in the tenancy agreement.

This doesn’t mean expecting a tenant to keep the property in perfect condition. Normal wear and tear is part of owning rental real estate, and landlords have their own legal obligations to maintain the premises.

What we’re trying to assess is whether there’s reliable evidence that the applicant is likely to take reasonable care of the property.

Previous rental history can be useful. Where available, we want to understand whether the applicant generally fulfilled their tenancy obligations, whether there were documented concerns about damage beyond normal wear and tear, and whether previous landlords can provide relevant references.

However, references need to be evaluated carefully. Not every reference is complete or reliable, and a landlord shouldn’t base a decision on gossip, subjective impressions or irrelevant personal information.

The application process and conversations with prospective tenants can also help clarify legitimate questions about the proposed tenancy. For example, we may need to confirm intended occupants, move-in dates or information that differs between documents.

The important thing is to use objective, tenancy-related information and apply the same lawful standards to applicants. Personal appearance, cultural differences, disability, family status or other protected characteristics should never be used as substitutes for evidence about how someone will care for a property.

I also think it’s important to recognize that someone without a long rental history isn’t automatically a poor candidate. First-time renters and people relocating may have limited references, but there may be other appropriate ways to assess their application.

Ultimately, no screening process can tell you with certainty how someone will behave in the future. The goal is to gather relevant information, evaluate it fairly and reduce avoidable risk.

3. If Something Goes Wrong, Can You Sue, Win and Actually Collect?

This is the third question, and it’s the one I believe many landlords overlook.

Most landlords understand that tenants are legally responsible for paying rent and meeting their obligations under the lease. What they don’t always appreciate is the difference between having a legal right to recover money and actually being able to collect it.

Let’s say a tenant stops paying rent and eventually owes several thousand dollars. The landlord may pursue a claim through Alberta’s Residential Tenancy Dispute Resolution Service or the courts, depending on the circumstances. If the landlord has the necessary evidence and succeeds, they may obtain an order or judgment for the money owed.

But winning doesn’t automatically mean getting paid.

The landlord may still need to take additional enforcement steps, and recovery can depend on the tenant’s financial circumstances, available assets or income, applicable exemptions and other legal considerations. Even with a valid judgment, collecting the full amount may be difficult or impossible.

I’ve seen how frustrating this can be for rental property owners. They may spend months dealing with unpaid rent, damage, legal proceedings and collection efforts, only to recover little or none of what they’re owed.

That’s why I believe collectability deserves consideration before a tenancy begins, rather than only after something goes wrong.

This doesn’t mean trying to predict someone’s future based on their background or making assumptions about who might be difficult to collect from. Screening must remain consistent and legally compliant. Instead, it means understanding the applicant’s verified financial circumstances and whether there are lawful, practical ways to reduce legitimate financial risks.

For example, if an application presents concerns about financial capacity or credit history, an appropriately qualified guarantor may provide additional contractual protection.

The important point is that a legal judgment and a successful collection are two separate outcomes.

As a landlord, I want to understand both before making a major financial decision.

The Eviction Process Starts Before the Tenant Moves In

There’s something I’ve believed for many years that might surprise some landlords: the eviction process starts when you approve the tenant, not when you serve an eviction notice.

Let me explain what I mean.

When you’re reviewing a rental application, you’re not just deciding whether someone can afford the first month’s rent. You’re making a decision that could affect your investment for years. You’re also deciding how much financial risk you’re prepared to accept if something goes wrong.

I’ve always believed that when you rent to responsible people who have demonstrated a history of meeting their obligations, you improve the chances of having a successful tenancy. Even when those tenants experience difficult circumstances, there’s a better chance they’ll communicate with you, work toward a solution and make a genuine effort to fulfill their responsibilities.

That’s not a guarantee. Good tenants can lose jobs, experience financial hardship or face unexpected personal challenges. But I believe a person’s demonstrated track record of responsibility is worth considering when making a rental decision.

This is also why the third question in our screening process matters so much: if the tenant doesn’t fulfill their obligations, can the landlord successfully pursue a legitimate claim and realistically collect what is owed?

Some landlords don’t think about that question until they’re already dealing with unpaid rent or property damage. By then, their options may be limited.

I prefer to consider those risks before the lease is signed. We look at relevant financial information, rental history and other lawful, verifiable evidence to make a responsible decision. When appropriate, a qualified guarantor may provide additional financial protection.

The objective isn’t to prepare for an eviction. It’s to reduce the likelihood of ever needing one, while understanding the financial consequences if a tenancy doesn’t work out.

A successful tenancy begins with a good approval decision. And if things do go wrong, that same decision can influence how effectively the landlord can protect their investment and recover legitimate losses.

What Happens if an Applicant Doesn’t Satisfy All Three Questions?

This is where our screening philosophy becomes particularly important.

Our goal is to be satisfied that an applicant can meet the rent obligations, is likely to care for the property and presents a reasonable level of financial accountability if something goes wrong.

If all three considerations are satisfactorily addressed, the application may be recommended for approval.

If a legitimate financial concern remains, we don’t necessarily have to reject the application immediately. In appropriate circumstances, we may consider a qualified co-signer or guarantor who can provide additional financial security.

A co-signer is someone who agrees, under a properly drafted and enforceable agreement, to take on specified financial responsibilities if the tenant fails to meet them. The exact obligations depend on the agreement and applicable law.

However, I think it’s important to understand what a co-signer can and cannot accomplish.

A qualified guarantor may strengthen the financial side of an application by providing an additional party against whom certain contractual obligations may be enforceable. But a co-signer cannot guarantee that a tenant will maintain the property properly, and their involvement doesn’t eliminate the need to evaluate the applicant fairly and thoroughly.

We still need to be comfortable with the overall tenancy arrangement and ensure any approval conditions are lawful and consistently applied.

A guarantor should also be properly screened for the obligations they’re agreeing to assume. Simply having someone sign a document doesn’t provide much protection if that person cannot realistically meet the financial commitments.

In my opinion, the objective isn’t to find a reason to approve every application or reject everyone who presents a concern. It’s to identify legitimate risks, determine whether they can be reasonably addressed and make a decision supported by the available information.

Why a Credit Check Alone Isn’t Enough

One of the questions I’d encourage landlords to ask their property management company is what happens after an application is submitted.

Some people assume tenant screening consists of reviewing the application, running a credit check and deciding whether the credit score is acceptable. But a credit report is only one part of the overall assessment.

Credit information may reveal missed payments, outstanding obligations or other financial concerns. It doesn’t necessarily establish whether the applicant will care for the property, whether their current financial circumstances have improved or whether all the information provided is accurate.

That’s why I believe screening should involve several stages.

At TILT, our process includes reviewing the application, communicating with prospective tenants, conducting showings, checking appropriate financial information, verifying relevant references and having multiple managers review the application before the owner makes the final decision.

Each stage serves a purpose. The application provides information, conversations help clarify details, financial checks assist with affordability assessments, and references may provide insight into previous tenancy obligations.

Having multiple managers review the application can also reduce the risk of overlooking something important. One person may notice an inconsistency or identify a question that another person didn’t consider.

I don’t believe any individual screening step is particularly impressive on its own. What matters is how the information is collected, verified, documented and evaluated together.

A strong process should produce a reasoned recommendation, not simply a yes-or-no decision based on one number.

The Cost of Getting Tenant Placement Wrong

To understand why tenant screening matters, consider a fairly straightforward example.

Imagine you own an Edmonton rental property generating $2,000 per month.

A tenant stops paying rent, and by the time the situation is resolved, you’ve lost three months of rental income. That’s $6,000.

Suppose the property also requires $4,000 in repairs beyond normal wear and tear. You’re now looking at a potential $10,000 loss, before considering additional vacancy, legal expenses, cleaning or other costs.

These figures are illustrative, but they show how quickly the financial consequences of a problematic tenancy can add up.

For many rental property owners, $10,000 represents a significant portion of the property’s annual cash flow. Depending on the investment, it could wipe out years of profit.

And the financial impact isn’t always the most frustrating part. There may also be considerable time spent documenting problems, communicating with tenants, coordinating repairs, attending hearings and attempting to recover money.

That’s why I don’t believe tenant placement should be judged solely by how quickly a property is rented.

A property that rents in three days may look like a success, but if the tenancy creates serious financial problems, that initial speed doesn’t mean very much.

On the other hand, taking reasonable time to verify an application and make an informed decision can help protect the investment over the long term.

The goal isn’t simply to fill the vacancy. It’s to establish a tenancy that has a reasonable chance of being successful.

Don’t Let Vacancy Pressure Change Your Screening Standards

I understand the pressure landlords feel when a property sits vacant. I’ve experienced it myself many times over the years.

When a property has been empty for several weeks, it’s tempting to focus entirely on getting someone moved in. But I believe that’s exactly when a landlord needs to remain disciplined.

There are two separate issues to consider.

The first is whether the property is priced appropriately for the market. If a property isn’t generating inquiries or showings, the asking rent may be too high compared with competing properties. If people are viewing the property but not applying, the condition, layout or overall value may not be meeting expectations.

Those are marketing and pricing problems that should be addressed.

The second issue is whether an applicant meets reasonable screening requirements.

Reducing the asking rent to reflect market conditions can be a smart business decision. Ignoring significant, unresolved screening concerns because the property has been vacant is something entirely different.

For example, suppose you’ve been advertising a property for six weeks and finally receive an application. The applicant initially looks promising, but the verification process reveals important inconsistencies that haven’t been satisfactorily explained.

Approving the application simply because you’re tired of losing rent could expose you to a much larger financial problem.

That doesn’t mean waiting indefinitely for a perfect tenant. No applicant is perfect, and unreasonable screening standards can create unnecessary vacancies and unfair outcomes.

It means establishing fair, lawful criteria in advance and applying them consistently, regardless of how long the property has been vacant.

Sometimes the best decision is to keep looking. Sometimes it’s to adjust the asking rent so the property attracts more suitable applicants. And sometimes a legitimate financial concern can be addressed through a properly qualified guarantor.

The important thing is making the decision for the right reasons.

Who Should Have the Final Say on Tenant Approval?

This is another question I believe landlords should ask before hiring a property management company.

Who actually approves the tenant?

Some companies make tenant placement decisions internally, while others involve the property owner in the final approval process.

Personally, I’ve always believed that the property owner should have the final say over who moves into their investment, provided the decision is based on lawful screening criteria.

After all, the owner is the person who ultimately bears many of the financial consequences if the tenancy doesn’t work out.

At TILT, our managers review the application and provide a recommendation, but the property owner makes the final approval decision.

I think that creates an important level of accountability. The manager is responsible for conducting a thorough review and explaining the results, while the owner remains involved in one of the most significant decisions affecting the investment.

That doesn’t mean the owner should be expected to interpret credit reports or independently investigate every reference. Those are responsibilities the management company should handle appropriately.

It also doesn’t mean a manager should participate in an unlawful or discriminatory decision. Professional screening requires consistent standards and compliance with applicable legislation.

The objective is to give the owner meaningful information and professional guidance so the final decision can be made responsibly.

What Should Edmonton Landlords Ask Their Property Manager?

If you’re currently using a property management company, I’d encourage you to ask how prospective tenants are evaluated before being approved.

You don’t necessarily need to understand every administrative step, but you should understand the company’s philosophy and how it protects your investment.

I’d want to know whether the company verifies relevant financial information, checks appropriate references, investigates inconsistencies and has a documented review process.

I’d also ask what happens when an application presents a legitimate concern. Does the company simply reject it? Does it investigate further? Are lawful options such as a qualified guarantor considered when appropriate?

Most importantly, I’d ask whether the screening process addresses all three of the questions I’ve discussed: the applicant’s ability to pay, their likely care of the property and the financial risks if they fail to meet their obligations.

About the Author

Jared Hope has been investing in real estate since 2003. After experiencing challenges with several property management companies, he began managing his own rental investments and established a property management business in 2010. The company was rebranded as TILT Property Group in 2017 and now manages approximately 860 residential rental properties in the Edmonton area.

Through Edmonton Property Management Insights, Jared shares practical lessons from more than two decades of investing, owning and managing rental properties.

TILT Property Group

Your Property. Your Money. Your Decisions.

Considering changing your Edmonton property management company? Let’s Talk About Your Property.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.